Monday, August 31, 2015

DVD Review: Barney Miller: The Final Season

Every once in a while a show will rise above its sitcom format, or do something special within that structure. Shows like M.A.S.H. and All In The Family come to mind as examples. And such a show was Barney Miller. The writing was really good, the characters completely fleshed out and original, and the acting quite good as well. The series lasted eight seasons, and managed to remain fresh and interesting and relevant right up to the end. It had warmth and intelligence and wit, and also more often than not had something important to say. And to think this show took place almost entirely on just one set – the detectives’ squad room, with Captain Miller’s office attached.

The show stars Hal Linden as Barney Miller, Max Gail as Stan “Wojo” Wojciehowicz, Ron Glass as Ron Harris, Steve Landesberg as Arthur Dietrich, and Ron Carey as Carl Levitt. Barney Miller: The Final Season includes all twenty-two episodes of the eighth season on three discs, plus lots of bonus material. These episodes originally aired in 1981-1982.

One of my favorite episodes of the season is “Stress Analyzer,” which features guest star James Cromwell as Dr. Danworth, from the center for stress studies. He’s there to collect data from Dietrich. There is also an elderly woman who accuses her husband of cheating and wants the police to run the other woman out of town. And a recruiter for the Peace Corps is angry at self-involved students (which is perfect, as this was the beginning of the awful Reagan years). This is an hilarious episode. I usually dislike Christmas episodes of shows, but “Homeless” is a good one, and it features a guest appearance by David Clennon as Howard Weckler. Clennon is an actor I always love to see, and he’s brilliant in this episode, as always. “The Tontine” features Ian Wolfe, whom you’ll recall as Mrs. Carlson’s butler in WKRP In Cincinnati. That episode also features a CPR instructor who has a special relationship with his dummy.

I like the way the show handles some serious subjects. In “Advancement,” a detective is unhappy about his impending retirement. He says, “Most people facing retirement, they got somebody else facing it with them.” This leads to his wanting to find an Asian bride to share his final miserable years, which becomes a running storyline throughout the season. There are a couple of other running storylines, like Harris’ writer’s block and Officer Levitt’s quest for promotion. By the way, it’s interesting how often the charges against suspects are dropped in these episodes.

There are so many great lines in this series. In “Games,” a nervous suspect says: “Please don’t let me go to jail. My wife hardly talks to me now.” And in “The Clown,” a criminal says: “I couldn’t make up my mind whether I wanted to go straight into med school or work in a hospital first, get some practical experience. So I robbed a shoe store and bought drugs.” Dietrich is my favorite character. I love his dry, intelligent humor. In “Obituary,” a woman asks, “Is there some place I could go to freshen up?” Dietrich replies, “No, but we have a bathroom.”

This season has two multi-part episodes. The first is “Chinatown,” in which a witness to a gang-related murder in Chinatown doesn’t want to testify or even offer any information. This two-part episode also features Joanna Barnes as a wealthy victim of a mugging, and in it she wears a gorgeous lynx coat. And the series’ finale is a three-part episode titled “Landmark,” in which the building that houses the twelfth precinct might be sold as an historic site. The first part opens with a man who has been robbed of every cent he owns. He says: “You see, I’ve been out of work for almost a year and a half. I was laid off on inauguration day” (a nice, subtle jab at Ronald Reagan). And a newly released hostage is arrested. His time as a hostage seems to have had some interesting effects on his outlook. This three-part episode is a nice way of wrapping up the series, long before the show was in any danger of becoming stale.

Special Features

This three-disc set includes several bonus features, all of which are on the third disc. There are commentary tracks on the final three episodes, all done by director Tony Sheehan and writers/producers Jeff Stein and Frank Dungan. The three joke around a bit, teasing each other. On the commentary track for “Landmark Part 1,” Tony Sheehan says, “The show pretty much directed itself.” On that commentary track, they talk about ending the show, about the “Chinatown” episode and about the writing process for this series. In the commentary for the second part, they talk about Danny Arnold as a director, and about how many of the series’ stories came from real life, from newspapers. And it’s so interesting to learn that the network wasn’t allowed to give notes on the show, which was probably one of the main reasons why the show was so good. In the commentary for the final episode, they talk about the show’s appeal to men.

Inside The 12th Precinct is a half-hour look at the series, featuring interviews with cast members Abe Vigoda, Hal Linden, Max Gail and Steve Landesberg (the Landesberg interview was filmed in 2009), as well as with writers/producers Frank Dungan and Jeff Stein. They talk about how there was a studio audience at the beginning, and why that stopped. Hal Linden talks about the original pilot. Salute To The Old One Two is basically a continuation of that featurette, in which the cast members talk about certain episodes, such as the hash brownies episode and the prostitute episode. Frank Dungan mentions that it was most difficult to write for the Barney character. This featurette is approximately twenty-four minutes. Inside The Writers Room features more of the interviews with Frank Dungan and Jeff Stein, who talk about how they became interested in the series, how they broke into comedy, and specifically about writing for this show, and how it differed from other situation comedies. This is approximately sixteen minutes.

Also included is The Life And Times Of Captain Barney Miller, the original pilot episode, which has a different cast and a very different opening title sequence. And then, for comparison, the uncut version of “Ramon,” the re-cast version of the pilot, is also included. The special features also include an excerpt from You Don’t Know Jack: The Jack Soo Story, a documentary on Jack Soo.

Barney Miller: The Final Season was released on DVD on July 7, 2015 through Shout! Factory.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Blu-ray Review: Cutting Class

There is an undeniable nostalgia for the music and movies of the 1980s, and certainly for the horror films of that decade. One film, howev...